I once opened a hymnal title page to find the most interesting charge. “After a Bible, the hymnal should be the most important book in the Christian’s life.” Yet, the church no longer touches them. The youngest and newest of Christians don’t even know what they are. Printed music in the church is a thing of the past.
The modern evangelical church has majorly given up on music literacy. I’m not advocating for church worship to only use hymns. I’m not even advocating for current worship songs to be sung in the style of hymns. I’m simply advocating for the church to know what they sing and why they sing it.
Too often, the bulletin (or the order of worship in a bulletin) is the first thing to go in our transition from the previous generation to the church today. Even if a church still has hymnals or song books, lyrics are presented on the screen and the congregation is not directed to turn to a written copy of the worship song. The song simply begins without letting the congregation know what they are about to sing. If a song speaks to them, they can’t turn to the bulletin to know what it is called. They can’t look down at the music they’re holding, because they’re not holding any.
I believe that providing the title of the song for the congregation allows the Holy Spirit to do so much more work than when the worship team runs through a seamless, unnamed set. In my life, there have been many worship songs I wanted to keep singing or listening to after the service ended, but I couldn’t remember enough of the lyrics and didn’t know the title to look them up later. I was called to carry those songs with me throughout my week, but I couldn’t, simply because it was determined for me that I did not need the title or the music in my hands.
This is not unlike when Scripture was read over congregations but they didn’t have personal copies of it, when the clergy alone held the text.
When someone is given the title of a song, they can look up the lyrics later, they know what songs God is using in their life, they can listen to recordings of them. They can look up the lyrics and reflect on them, they can discover what Scripture the song is based on.
In addition to knowing the title of songs, this ownership and engagement would only increase if the church could read music. If they weren’t reliant on a leader alone to teach them the melody, but were able to follow along with the melody and see and know what they are to do. I am advocating for worship leaders to give the same charge that a pastor would give before starting his sermon. “Turn with me in the text, open your Bible, see what it says, follow along with me.” With music, the lyrics on the screen are not always enough. Though it’s not necessary for every single congregant to follow along with sheet music for every single worship song, imagine how powerful it would be if the church were called to engage with worship in the same way they are called to engage with the Holy Scriptures, with the truth of Scripture set to melody.
Even though we are invited to sing, the church’s worship today calls back to a time when singing was only for the clergy. Too often people stand there, not really singing. It’s because they haven’t been taught how to. They don’t feel capable or comfortable of lifting their voice in song to their Savior because they can’t match pitch, because they don’t know if they’re supposed to go higher or lower, because the song is set in a difficult key and they don’t know how to sing harmony, because they’re ashamed of their voice.
Imagine if families had a book of hymns and worship songs at home with them that they could study together and learn to sing parts together. If the husband is the pastor of his family, then that most certainly includes creating a plan for worship. Imagine if, just as the we carry Scripture beyond the walls of the service, we also carried the charge to know and study Scripture through song. To reclaim the music literacy that we have willingly handed off to the secular world. Imagine if the congregation could read music and carry a tenacity, a desire, to be shaped by the lyrics. Imagine if, at worship nights, the church chose one or two songs to separate into parts and helped each other learn how to use their voices, the instruments entrusted to us.
We have a responsibility as the church to sing and know theologically rich songs. To let God’s Spirit work in our hearts through the gift of music and worship. To know how to read music and to worship with beauty and skill. God has called us to use our hearts and minds to wonder at His gift of music. May we be obedient to that call.